TV news reports about breast-cancer detection and treatment are common, though usually discreet, with female breasts typically depicted only in X-rays or tastefully draped.For obvious reasons (AB.com is a SFW, PG-13 blog. I even sensor my curses for crissakes!) I am not running the video here, but you can catch it on the WJLA website if you'd like to.
But in a four-part report on the disease beginning Thursday night, WJLA, Channel 7 in Washington, will break TV's unspoken taboo by showing two women fully exposed on its late-afternoon and evening newscasts.
The station says its reports are meant to encourage proper breast self-examination, and are being aired in conjunction with National Breast Cancer Awareness month, which ends Saturday.
WJLA acknowledges, however, that the timing of its stories may raise some eyebrows: The reports will air on the first two days of TV's traditional "sweeps" month, a period in which stations air their most eye-catching stories to boost ratings that are used to set advertising rates.
WJLA general manager Bill Lord said he had no qualms about the timing of the reports, or in promoting them beforehand. "People will say we're doing it just for ratings," he said. "But we're a commercial television station -- we're trying to get people to watch us. Yes, this is an attention-getting story, but it's also an important story."
The station's first report features a 28-year-old woman from Northern Virginia, Lauren Albright, who volunteered to be led through an on-camera self-exam by an oncologist. She is shown examining her bare torso in a mirror and on an examination table, in both close-up and medium shots. Reporter Gail Pennybacker says in a voice-over that Albright took the "extraordinary step of baring herself" to teach women how to do the exam.
I suppose you could read this either of two ways.
Considering how much an epidemic breast cancer is for women (and to a far lesser degree, men, who are indeed susceptible), using a graphic demonstration to show women how to correctly perform a breast exam is a daring, and laudable effort.
On the flipside, let's keep it one hunned, these folks know exactly what they're doing. ABC 7, despite paying Leon Harris a zillion dollars a year, still trails Jim Vance and NBC 4 in the ratings by a country mile. DC local news is media bloodsport, and doing this to give WJLA a leg up during sweeps week is jive suspect. There's also the reality that they had all month (how many pink bows did you see in October?) to run such a report, yet waited till the last minute to capitalize on ratings. And yeah, boobs = ratings. Do you really think this station would run a graphic prostate cancer exam? I sure as hell wouldn't tune in to that. Taking one in real life is "real and graphic" enough for me.
That said, I'm all for this report. I watched it, and trust me, there was nothing arousing about it in the least bit. If it educates even one woman about how to properly examine herself, and saves one person from dying, it was worth it.
I still wish ABC 7 would just keep it real tho'.
Question: Is ABC 7 being genuinely concerned about the welfare and health of DC area women, or do they simply see the guaranteed ratings grab that naked boobs on the 5 o'clock news can bring?
TV report on breast self-exams bares all [WashPost]



14 AverageComments™:
I say no big deal. Apart from the odd disease fetishist out there (Why not? There's a fetish for everything imaginable), I think most of us can agree that the subject of cancer removes anything even remotely sexy about gazongas. Context is king, even for gazongas. I think it's safe to bet that gazongas bared in the context of cancer exams will be seen as purely functional by everyone (except for the hyperventilating media moralizers who see Janet Jackson lurking around every corner.)
But yes, the timing is terrible. XP
Breasts are amazing. They feed and nuture babies.
This is the most modern country. Yet only in this dreadful country are a woman's breasts considered so taboo.
Where a woman feeding her child in public, is accepted with horror.
I say, if a man can be shown topless on television, then so should a woman.
Its not as if they were having sex. Its educational!
This country needs to stop pretending to be prudish. When the teenage pregnancy, hiv rates and single motherhood numbers drop, then I'll believe we really are.
Being of the belief that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, I think the educational benefit out weighs the discomfort some might experience. If I let the health nut in me speak, first and foremost a person's body is the partner to their mind in life. It lets them work, play, and survive. The more people understand how their body works and how to take care of it the better.
I didn't see the need to to show a woman's real breast. A woman will get no more benefit out of the use of actual breast then would a mannequin or diagram. What we allow speaks volumes of who we are. Ridiculous
Why are we, Black Folk, so hung up on nudity? It is the context in which nudity is used that causes the problems, not the content itself. This context will save lives.
I don't care if it is the sweeps or not, the message needs to get out, especially to Black women. It's not just about feeling for lumps, there are visible things that can change like size and color. I don't think that a mannequin will show that effectively.
We don't want to talk about sex and look where we are with HIV/AIDS. What do we as black folk want to face?
I figured this was already done before. I'm not in DC, so I'm unaware of media habits. Elsewhere...???
Kim, I have to disagree. Mannequin and diagram breast aren't 'real' breasts. They don't move or change in shape or size. They're one-size-fits all false examples of what real breasts are. Even women with breast implants can benefit from real examples of exams.
I liken it to a medical student using real cadavers as opposed to those surgical dummies with removable parts or the game Operation.
A student can practice on those examples day, but I wouldn't let them attempt to remove my human appendix because they mastered it on fake parts.
Whether the network's motive was ratings or prevention, I'm all for it. They're breasts for goodness sakes! I've seen more in some rated R movies shown on cable. And no I do not think that the station would air a prostate exam. I think you definitely cross the line with anything in the genital area.
I saw the report on WJLA. I doubt it was a coincidence that the women's breasts were significantly small (as in barely an A cup). Clearly the station tried to play it safe with the least "threatening" body type they could find.
In real life, no one does a self breast exam over clothes. The best way to demonstrate it is the way it would actually be done. Period. They're just breasts. I really wish, as a country, we'd just stop acting like our bodies, just by existing, are crude.
And no, I don't think the station would air a prostate exam, because physicians perform prostate exams. You don't NEED to see how to properly do it. Women NEED to know how to do a self breast exam.
If you're watching the five o'clock news waiting for the breast exam jawn because wifey isn't home and you need some... satisfaction... I would suggest you stop being cheap and subscribe to Cinemax.
It's stuff like this that makes me completely unsurprised that we're the only industrialized nation of our weight class that doesn't have healthcare.
With any luck, naked boobs on the news is included somewhere in the Healthcare Bill... :-)
@organize: The only industrialized nations in our weight class are China and India (ish). One has no healthcare, and one has no freedom.
Obvious rating ploy but considering the how much breast cancer effects so many any type of information or awareness is a good thing. I just wish more attention was focused on prostate cancer in men especially because its higher fatality rates in black men do to lack of screenings and preventive care. Well I know prostate exams aren’t going to win over any ratings sweep but it definitely needs more attention than its getting.
@ organized_Crime – lol yea if naked boobs during a breast on TV news is your only excitement then wow.
you can find the difference between both when you have the experience of a educational sex video
if you want to watch the video it is here http://survivorboobs.blogspot.com/2009/11/wjla-washington-breast-exam-video-abc-7.html
Post a Comment